Welcome to Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza
Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza in Saint Petersburg, FL, is a beloved local spot known for its delicious Italian cuisine. Customers rave about the authentic flavors of the pizza, sandwiches, and salads. The welcoming atmosphere, quick service, and family-run charm make it a go-to destination for pizza lovers. Reviews highlight the generous portions, quality ingredients, and the unique touch of a mock subway sign outside. With a range of options like the White Plain Pizza and Steak & Cheese Philly Steaks, Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza is a must-visit for a taste of classic, mouthwatering dishes.
-
3523 49th St N Saint Petersburg, FL 33710 Hotline: (727) 522-2717
Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza is a gem located in Saint Petersburg, FL, offering a delectable selection of Italian pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. Their menu features mouth-watering options such as the White Plain Pizza, Chef Salad, and Steak & Cheese Philly Steaks. Customers rave about the generous portions, flavorful toppings, and quality ingredients used in each dish.
With a variety of utilities like delivery, takeout, and catering services, Toby's ensures that their delicious food is easily accessible to all. The casual atmosphere, outdoor seating, and friendly staff create a welcoming environment for diners of all ages.
Reviews from satisfied customers reflect the excellence of Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza, with praises for the crispy crust, cheesy slices, and quick service. Whether you're a pizza enthusiast or simply looking for a satisfying meal, Toby's is the perfect spot for a classic pizza parlor experience. Make sure to visit Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza for an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of Florida!
The best pizza I've had since leaving NJ! I wish the crust was a tiny bit thicker like home but it was delicious. My lunch mates loved their food as well,; pepperoni boll, sausage sandwich. Even converted a meatball sub aficionado from his former favorite place! Nice people though minimal interaction. Cleaning the tables would improve that. Quick service. Loved the mock subway sign out front!! My new go to classic pizza parlor food.
Best pizza since my last trip to NYC! Definitely on par. I truly didn't believe it but ate it tonight for dinner on a recommended! Did not disappoint!!!
My favorite local pizza place! Order by the slice or get the entire pie. Order at the counter, and enjoy your food at the booth or take it home. Family run, the greeting is always warm here
Great casual little place with quick friendly service. Food was excellent! Slices were large, cheesy and with great crust. Stromboli was so good! Will definitely return!
Omg, GREAT PIZZA!!! I was shopping in the plaza and came across this pizza place and started reading the reviews and had to pick up a pie! It did not disappoint! It was a huge and very tasty pizza! Can't wait to come back
Great lil spot for a quick pizza fix. The pizza is fresh and the crust is crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The pizza isn't greasy and they get the orders out fast. $2.99 a slice of cheese. $2.39 for a fountain drink. They have plenty of booth seating for a pizza joint including tables for a large party.
I stopped here recently because of the Dave Portnoy review. I think his review was spot on. Really good pizza. They were super busy when I arrived and I hadn't called in my order. I just ordered at the counter and waited. It wasn't too long before they called my #. My guess is approx 15 minutes. I ate 2 slices in the car and then took the rest home. I ate the leftover pizza over the next two days (I have a GREAT way of reheating pizza). I enjoyed it fresh and I enjoyed it reheated. I am really happy to report that they use real sliced sausage, Not that ground up junk. My only (minor) complaint is that it could have been cooked just a little bit more. I will definitely go back again when I am in the area. Obviously, this review is only for the pizza. I haven't tried anything else yet.
Love this little chain mall shop. It can get quite busy so I'd recommend ordering ahead unless you don't mind waiting. The pizza is on point!! Delicious and goes down way too easy. Different kind soda pops in glass bottles as options as well. My friend LOVES their salad because the dressing. I've tried their garlic knots, also pretty on point. Definitely worth a try if you're craving pizza!!!